In the ongoing saga of the TB lawyer, we now hear he might face surgery to remove the TB.
In some ways, doctors are glad about this lawyer’s immature behavior, including his manipulation of the press, because at least he was only minimally infectious, but the soapopera like press story has brought the importance of drug resistant TB to the public attention.
In summary, the next time, instead of being polite and saying we advise you not to travel, (knowing the law makes enforcement impossible and knowing some patients will balk at cooperation if they are given a direct order) we will be able to say: don’t travel or we’ll get you arrested by Homeland security and placed into jail.
But the next stop is treatment. How do you treat Tuberculosis when medicine doesn’t work?
Ah, back to the good old days.
You put the person at rest, either at home or somewhere he or she won’t spread the germ, give them good nutrition, and if the disease is localized, you can consider surgery.
The tuberculosis germ is usually walled off by the body, sort of like a boil with cheesy stuff inside.
If you’ve ever had a boil, you know what I mean. It’s pretty nasty. But when boils burst, the germs go out and you get better. If it bursts in your lungs, it spreads germs through your lungs and you cough out germs. Bursting the wall can also lead to you bleeding to death (hemoptysis) but that’s another story.
IF you want a gory picture of what it looks like, check
…
The holes are areas that used to be full of germs and white blood cells (actually t cell macrophages) but have emptied out…the photo shows the gentleman coughing germs galore all over the place. Usually tuberculosis likes the upper lungs, and the danger is that as you cough it out, it spreads down to the rest of the lung, which is why the picture shows holed in the top and grey-yellow areas (tubercules that haven’t burst) in the middle of the lung.
But our lawyer didn’t break down the walls, so wasn’t that infectious…yet. He isn’t a malnourished Asian like the photo, but a healthy lawyer. So how do you keep him from getting worse if you can’t treat the infection?
In the good old days, if you only have one or two tubercules/ puspockets/areas of infection, it was removed surgically. Usually these people do well–I had a couple little old ladies patients who had it done in the 1930’s, and they were still going strong fifty years later. Indeed, this is how we treat certain fungus infections. And for our lawyer, it sounds like a good idea, although I worry about those in the operating room…
Like an abcess (boil, pimple) you can just take the tubercule out and voila, the infection in that area is gone.
Since this cuts down the number of germs that can get lose, and if the gentleman is lucky he doesn’t have a bunch of other tubercules elsewhere,, essentially it allows your own body defenses to kill the few remaining germs.
—————————-
Nancy Reyes is a retired physician living in the rural Philippines. Her website is Finest Kind Clinic and Fishmarket, and she writes essays on medicine at HeyDoc Xanga Blog
















1 user commented in " The soapopera continues: TB lawyer facing surgery "
Follow-up comment rss or Leave a TrackbackHi,
I just found this site while exploring the internet, and while I’ve never left a comment or even used the internet much, I’m compelled to comment on this because at the time I was so interested in the story. (I grew up on Nancy Drew books….)
I remember when this story first broke, I was convinced this guy was shady. Then I hear that his new father-in-law is a who’s who at the DCD. Then I saw the interview he and his “wife” gave after their whirlwind honeymoon. Then I saw all the places they/he(?) “visited”.
Here is what I think, strictly hypothetical, of course….
Andrew Speaker and his father in law were hired to spread an infectious disease by ?. When Andrew messed it up they came up with the honeymoon story and brought in the Dr.s daughter to give the story credibility in case anyone suspected the travel plans would give them away. After all, whos’ to say it’s not true? The perfect cover. However, if you watch the exchange between Andrew and the new wife during a news interview, it seems obvious that this theory could hold water. Mr. Speaker barely acknowledeges his new bride and seems agitated by her presence. he barely let’s her speak. I just don’t believe their relationship is real.
Why was he so determined to finish his travel plans????? Was the wife with him the entire time? Did he go to all the places he was scheduled to go to? Were they behaving as if they were on their honeymoon? Did they interact with other people on their trip? How would these people describe their attitudes towards each other? Did they appear to be madly in love? Look at the places on their trip. They could just as easily have been chosen as strategic global points where biological elements could be released to do the greatest harm.
Everything about this story makes more sense if you look at it as though it was a premeditated act of terrorism which was easily whitewashed. I don’t think he had TB at all. I think he more likely had little vials of who knows what. Test results can be easily faked I would imagine…especially if your partner in crime works at the CDC. and has access to records. Would this person also have access to viruses? Maybe they weren’t hired. Maybe they made their own deal with God knows who for God knows how much $$$$$$$$$$. When the plan turned sour perhaps they reasoned that if Andrew was thought to have TB, it would be better than if he was found to be involved in the unthinkable, which would put everyone involved under a spotlight.
The fiance just happens to be the daughter of the Dr. (researcher?) at the CDC? That’s convenient isn’t it?
Andrew says he wanted to finish his honeymoon and that’s why he didn’t obey “orders” to not travel. If that was the case one would expect to see a happy couple madly in love. When did they announce their engagement? Is their any news on how long they were engaged? When was the wedding? Was it planned for a while? What friends were in attendance?
I’ve obviously not kept up on this and maybe I’m way off, but I was wondering if any of these people have been investigated for the type of thing I’m suggesting because I just don’t buy it and I’ll bet they haven’t been…
Thanks for the time and place to comment.
Leave A Reply