I’m opposed to slavery reparations, so I was pretty sympathetic when I read Michelle Malkin’s post denouncing a new bill that would give reparations to Japan’s World War II victims in Guam. After all, if anyone should pay them reparations, Japan should. (Guam has been a US territory since 1898, and Japan invaded it during WWII.)
Here’s the bill.
However, there’s a major nuance here Malkin (and those she cites) misses. After World War II, the US government did more to help mainland US citizens than to help those residing in US territories. Guam was particularly hard hit — indeed, brutalized both by the Japanese invasion and the American recapture — and thus needed help as much as any area did.
The new bill implements the recommendations of the Guam War Claims Review Commission, and one advocate testifying before that commission said:
There has been some discussion on the directive to “determine whether there was parity of war claims paid to residents of Guam under the Guam Meritorious Claims Act as compared with awards made to other similarly affected United States citizens or nationals in territory occupied by the Imperial Japanese military forces during World War II”. This is the heart of the “fairness” issue and the sense among Guamanians that Guam has not been treated equally.
Here’s the commission’s report, which found the Japanese were “oppressive, cruel, and barbaric.” As for America’s postwar response, Guam was “one of the U.S. Navy’s first priorities” but:
[T]here was a lack of parity in some aspects of the process and the amounts made available for payment to the residents of Guam.
That doesn’t sound like a major injustice — certainly not compared to what Japan did — but it’s clear the US didn’t treat the territory as well as it did its own citizens.
We can debate how much the US owes residents of its territories, and we can ask how far into the past we should go to right wrongs. (In particular, it’s immoral to try to settle the scores of long-dead people by transferring wealth between live ones; that’s only one of my objections to slave reparations.) But it’s not fair to dismiss the issue out-of-hand, as if the US is being expected to atone for Japan’s sins. Rather, the bill gives money to people, many of whom are still alive, for a lack of parity in post-World War II aid.
Loading ...
13 users commented in " The case for Guam reparations "
Follow-up comment rss or Leave a TrackbackThe men of the 3rd Marine Division, the 1st Provisional Marine Brigade, the 77th Infantry Division and the United States Navy paid everything the United States owes.
3000 service men died to free Guam. That is 1 service member for every 3 citizens of Guam. Reparations are to be paid (legally) to the individual(s)by the individual(s) who committed the crime. Should most of Europe get reparations from us for what Germany did? What about Poland for the acts of Russia? Maybe we owe the Carthaginians for what Rome did? Guam did not become any part of the U.S. until 1950. So if France joined the U.S., we now owe them money? So this is the Democrats plan for America? Can’t wait until they cry about a deficit again.
I heard about this new plan yesterday on the way home yesterday. I am completely opposed to this idea. America did not commit this crime, Japan did. Liberals are tearing this country apart and pursuing ideas, I have yet to understand. How about all the funding we send Guam each time it is hit by a typhoon and the lack accountability of the funds. Guam received millions of dollars in aid for previous hurricane disasters and the government still can not account for how that money was spent. The people of Guam receive all the benefits of US citizens and answer to their own laws and corrupt government.
When the US Navy offered to for half of the cost for a new water treatment facility, the offer was refused, because they wanted it paid in full and the Navy to install it for them.
Although, the people are friendly… For the most part they are lazy and want everything handed to them on a silver platter.
The US was dragged into WWII by the Japanese… We do not owe a people for saving them from slavery.
The United States had forgiven Japan and prevented any compensation
to be paid to the residents of Guam.
The U.S. acquired Guam from Spain in 1898, but did not give the residents of Guam
U.S. citizenship.
The U.S. new of the impending war with Japan, or attack and seizure of the island of Guam
by the Japanese, but chose to ignore it and remove all U.S. citizens from Guam and
the residents of Guam. The residents of Guam had to fend for themselves.
The U.S. should pay, and then collect from Japan.
Correction:
The U.S. did not evacuate the residents of Guam. Only
U.S. citizens were evacuated from the island of Guam.
The US government made one critical mistake with regard to Guam and the post war reparations from Japan. The US government forgave Japan for its atrocities on Guam and relieved Japan from having to pay war reparations to the people of Guam.
…..without consulting the people of Guam.
By the treaties that ended the war Guam is barred from seeking war reparations from Japan. No representatives of the people of Guam were signatories to these treaties.
There is another way to make this right for the people of Guam. Lift the restrictions that prevent Guam for seeking war reparations directly from Japan.
The people of Guam remain loyal and grateful to the sacrifices of american soldiers on Guams behalf as evidences by the Liberation Day festivities every year. The american soldiers who fought for Guam have always been treated as they should be. As heroes. We live with that reality every day.
By the way Ms Crawford, racist much?
guam
dude, i’m sooooooooo dumb. i didn’t even know guam was a state until i read this. LOL. boy, am i stupid.
don’t really have a solid opinion on this issue at the moment. i just think guam should get the same treatment as the other states. all states should be treated equally.
guam is rarely ever mentioned in the media. as already stated, i didn’t even know guam was a state until JUST NOW. LOL.
so i can see how the us government forget to give guam it’s share of money. so if that’s the case, the governemnt needs to do what is right, and pay guam, plus a late penalty, to be fair.
that will prevent the government from forgeting one of their states again. and it’s been a long time since WWII ended, so the penalty needs to be pretty big. to be fair. plus, things cost a lot more than back then, so the money to guam, including the late penalty, needs to be adjusted for inflation.
i had heard of guam before but it didn’t really click in my mind that it was a state. i thought it was a city on the west coast or hawaii.
stay in schoool kids, HAHAHAHA.
In response to David Adkins, Guam was not a foreign country to the U.S. during WWII, Guam became a possession of the U.S. in December 1898 during the signing of the treaty of Paris only in 1950 when Guam became an unincorporated U.S. territory and the people of Guam were given limited rights under the constitution as American citizens. Also I honor the men that gave their lives to liberate Guam from its occupation from Japan we also have been honoring them for the last 64 years and will continue to honor them, but wait what about the people of Guam that suffered in the hands of Japan with the atrocities they committed against the people of Guam for staying loyal to the U.S. and the Chamorro families that were executed for protecting an American sailor from being captured. The people of Guam did not ask for this war nor did they want it. Both sides have lost loved ones during this war. The U.S. relived Japan of it’s responsibilities of reparations so it only fair that the U.S. takes responsibility for it’s actions. To Miss Crawford,there has never been a hurricane disaster in Guam let alone in the Pacific Ocean last time I checked the only storm system equivalent to a hurricane are typhoons and in response to the federal government aid of millions of dollars given to Guam this is true but as far as corruption and accountability the U.S. in the past only gave or granted money if it benefits them Guam is a Strategic location in the pacific with military bases on Guam the Fed Govt grants the aid and rebuilds their bases and whats left over is given to the people of Guam which is hardly nothing, take the State of Louisiana and it’s Katrina victims FEMA was the one that was corrupted as far as your comment of the people of Guam being lazy you don’t know the people in that way to comment that, I take your comment as an ignorant person or maybe your racist.
As Guam was a U.S. Territory, it was the obligation of the United States to defend her against the Japanese during WWII. Further, even if Guam had not been a U.S. Territory and the U.S. had not had a particular obligation to defend it as such, it certainly would have defended and held it out of recognition of Guam’s strategic importance to the general defense of Hawaii and the US mainland. Do you all know that the US is ramping up its military presence on Guam because of its strategic importance? While this does bring income to the island, it doesn’t do it without leaving a huge footprint and changing the face of the island in none too small ways. The people of Guam have coexisted with the U.S. military for generations and have endured some heartache because of it. Isn’t it right that those who suffered during the war at least should be given compensation? I’m divided about whether or not the money should be doled out to survivors in cases where the victim is deceased–that might like a bit of a stretch in intention all these years later. I would leave debate about that particular point to those more closely involved with the issue.
I’ve heard people speak and blog against war reparations stating that the US should have no obligation to Guam, since it is a “foreign country.” I’ve also heard them state that the US freed Guam out of the goodness of its heart. Such ignorance! Guam is not a foreign country my fellow Americans (yes, I am a U.S. citizen born, raised, educated, and contributing in California), nor did the US defend it only out of a sense of moral duty. There were U.S. military and civilians living on Guam during the invasion. Had the U.S. not taken action, wouldn’t we now be discussing reparations for the U.S. citizens who died on Guam because the U.S. did nothing to defend the island? It’s okay for us to send loads of money in aid to Louisiana or Haiti, for example, but not to aid our fellow Americans on Guam, even these many years after the fact? It should have been done back then. I hope it will be soon.
To Rochelle Crawford, I can’t begin to understand how you can make a generalization about an entire population of people the way you did in your blog, “For the most part they are lazy and want everything handed to them on a silver platter.” Do you personally know all or most of the people of Guam? Unless you do, you are not qualified to make that statement. There are lazy people in all walks of life, representing all races, in every corner of this earth. I hardly think Guam corners the market on laziness and who are you to decree it as such! I think you owe the people of Guam, and the people on this blog, an apology. Your other points may have been better received and/or at least given some consideration had you not thrown in that gross bit of overgeneralization; it took away your credibility and leads many to believe you are ignorant.
The people of Guam are hardly lazy.
The people of Guam do not pay into the US treasury with their tazes. All of their taxes wstay in Guam. THey should not and are not full citizens as far as I am concerned until or unless they pony up like the rest of us.
I have lived in Guam with an open mind and heart for years and I’ve come to this conclusion: The majority of the people of this island ( and surrounding islands that come here i.e. Truk, Yap, Kwajalein etc.) are very lazy and would love nothing more than the check on 1st and 15th. Also, my wife is from another country and it was harder for her to get a legal job (after it was offered)than it would’ve been for her to get federal assistance had she been not married to me. Wait for the next typhoon so you can get FIMA money. Go recycle some of thos Anheiser cans laying everywhere. Get off your asses Guahan- or learn how to swim a long way. I love Guahan- I hate the laziness and acceptance of substandard lifestyles and education.—PEACE
Leave A Reply