Earlier this week I wrote about a Federal Judge which upheld censorship in a public school. The decision came in response to a student who wished to protest the “Day of Silence” which encourages students to show visible support for homosexual lifestyle by refusing to speak during the school day, while conveying written messages in the form of T-shirts, buttons, and stickers, all of which promote homosexual behavior.
Yesterday a Michigan student was suspended yesterday for writitng the words “I’m Straight” on a piece of duct tape and p[lacing it on his T-Shirt.
A Christian student has been punished by his Michigan high school for demonstrating opposition to a school event celebrating the homosexual lifestyle. The boy’s father, a pastor, says he’s frustrated the rights of Christian students are being constantly trampled on campus.
Oakridge High School in Muskegon, Michigan, is one of many schools across the U.S. that took part in Wednesday’s “National Day of Silence” — an event promoted heavily by homosexual activist groups, which view it as a day to protest alleged discrimination faced by students who identify as “gay, lesbian, bisexual, or transgender (GLBT).” At Oakridge High, duct tape was passed out for students to wear over their lips as a way to show solidarity with homosexual students who are purportedly suffering in silence.
John Gardner is pastor of Holton Family Life Worship Center in Holton, a community of approximately 2,500 about 17 miles northeast of Muskegon. Pastor Gardner says his 15-year-old son David, a student at Oakridge High, was suspended for a day by the school because he wrote with a black marker “I’m straight” on a piece of duct tape and attached it to his shirt. He explains that David donned the message to voice his objection to the school’s participation in the Day of Silence.
“They asked him, at that point, to take it off,” Gardner says, “and David [asked] why do the rest of the kids in the class get to wear theirs and I can’t wear something about what I believe?” According to the pastor, the teacher then instructed David to remove the message or he would be “kicked out” of class. “And he said, ‘Well then, you’ll have to kick me out’ — and that’s what they did,” says David’s father.
In the previous article I wrote on the matter I recieved some comments from people stating the phrase “Be Happy, Not Gay” could be offensive to certain individuals. My response was to remind them the First Amendment protects even offensive speech, which is why the Al Sharptons of the country have national podiums to speek from. In this case however, we are not dealing with offensive speech in any way shape or form. This student was punished for expressing an oppossing opinion to the schools pro homosexual propoganda.
The idea that one student can wear a shirt that says “I’m Gay” and another student in the same class can not wear something proclaiming “I’m Straight” is in direct conflict with the First Amendment and all relevant Supreme Court cases. The school was not attempting to stifle offensive speech, it was participating in censorship of an oppossing view.
What is most offensive about situations like this, is the student should never have been put in a position where he felt it was necessary to proclaim his sexuality. The “Day of Silence” has no place in a public school. Parents pay taxes, and students goto school in order to learn the essentials such as Math and Science.
I wonder how our public school system would feel if there was a “Day of Silence” to represent the million plus baby’s a year whose cries are silenced before they are born by abortion doctors?















9 users commented in " Hypocrisy of Free Speech in Schools "
Follow-up comment rss or Leave a TrackbackCourts, including the Supreme Court, have repeatedly ruled that the right to free speech does not extend into schools as an absolute, and that schools may ban speech which interferes with or disrupts education. While I think banning “I’m straight” as a message is ridiculous, “Be happy not gay” is very offensive, and could be banned on the basis that it could incite violence in the school.
It’s notable that participants in the so called “day of truth” have sued schools which have banned their hate messages… and the schools have won.
I have to ask, where else can I find information on this incident. I like to ensure I have all available facts before forming an opinion about something, but I can find no mention of this incident anywhere other than here and onenewsnow, both site easily could be considered biased reporting, and I prefer truth….but no matter what I search I can only find mention of it here and there hrm
I don’t think it’s a matter of free speech as much as it is of bullying. The students with the anti-gay shirts are clearly bullies who don’t like gay students. This is just as offensive as any other form of bullying that happens in schools. I support the school for taking this action against the bullies.
A. The Day of Silence is about solidarity with GLBT students suffering hateful treatment in silence. In other words, it’s anti-violence / anti-hate. Not “pro-gay.” While proclaiming “I’m straight” shouldn’t garner ejection from class (perhaps some questions from teachers as to why it’s necessary to wear such a silly thing), the student’s actions were still based on a pretty fundamental misinterpretation of the actions of his peers.
“What is most offensive about situations like this, is the student should never have been put in a position where he felt it was necessary to proclaim his sexuality.” It seems you’re misinterpreting things the same way. I’m sure many of the anti-violence students were straight.
B. “I wonder how our public school system would feel if there was a ‘Day of Silence’ to represent the million plus baby’s a year whose cries are silenced before they are born by abortion doctors?” There is, and - at least at my school - it goes off without a hitch (though not without some thoughtful debate amongst the student body).
Considering the source of the article, and somewhat biased phrases such as “a day to protest alleged discrimination faced by students who identify as “gay, lesbian, bisexual, or transgender (GLBT),” I think that there is information missing from this article. I’m from one of the most liberal towns in perhaps the most liberal state in the US (Massachusetts), and my school would never consider throwing a kid out of class for wearing an “I’m Straight” sign on the National Day of Silence. Furthermore, there is no source material from people supporting the school, so all we have to go on are the words of a pissed off dad. I think the kid may have been intentionally or inadvertently disrupting class and that is why the teacher asked him to remove the sign.
Freedom of Speech folks, it applys to all equaly. Freedom of expression should also apply equaly but for some reason in the minds of the Politicaly Correct that’s not the case.
By the way Political Correctness is a state of mind, not reality as some may wish it was.
Let’s get real here, these are children we are talking about, not politicians,Jesse Jacksons,or Al Sharpton’s who wish to have it both ways.
I am from Oakridge and I know for a fact that he was not alone. He got infuriated from the people demonstrating the day of silence and decided he would stir things up with a “Its great to be straight” sign being taped on his shirt. The people demonstrating were also asked to take off their signs. Also he was not suspended. He just was given the choice to go home instead of staying at school because of the major controversy.
Also i was one of the people participating in the day of silance and I am straight
The biggest problem with this “news story” is that it is a one-sided account written by one student’s father (Rev. Gardner) and distributed by him to the conservative media with no one taking the time to fact-check the story to see if dad was reporting correctly the way the school handled the day or his son. There is much more to this story and anyone who passes along or posts Rev. Gardner’s account without concern for the rest of the story of what happened at Oakridge High School is as irresponsible as Rev. Gardner. (Who, by the way, put on his church’s sign that “Our Easter bunny is saved, sanctified and Spirit filled” What on earth??!!)
Leave A Reply