The much awaited ruling was made today in the murder case against Casey Anthony in Orlando Florida. Judge Belvin Perry made his decision today and ruled against two of the major motions filed by Anthony’s defense team last week.
Anthony is in the Orange County jail and is being charged with first degree murder of her 2 year old daughter, Caylee Anthony in June of 2008.. The state is asking for the death penalty if she is found guilty
A motion filed asked the judge to throw out statements Anthony had said to the investigators when Caylee was first reported missing. Their argument was that since Casey was not read her Miranda Rights, her statements should not be allowed during the trial. They argued that she was essentially in custody and the investigators had interrogated her.
Although they admitted to handcuffing Anthony for a short time, she was never considered a suspect at the time.
Judge Perry noted the legal importance of the fact that it was Cindy Anthony, in her 911 call that summoned the officers to her home. It was not them summoning Casey Anthony so there was no need for her to be read her Miranda rights. He also stated that the trip Anthony made to Universal Studios with the officers was done of her own free will, she was not forced to go.
In the second motion ruled on today, the defense argued that investigators used members of Anthony’s family as so-called “agents of the stateâ€. The defense argued that while investigators worked on the case trying to build it, they were manipulating the Anthony family to get information from Casey to find Caylee and report back to them.
Judge Perry pointed out that Anthony’s family testified under oath that they were doing what ever they could to get information out of Casey so they could find Caylee. So that knocks out any accusations from the defense team about the family being used solely as “agents of the stateâ€.
Other motions were ruled today as well.
The state’s Motion to Strike the Defendant’s Motion to Exclude Unreliable Evidence (Plant or Root Growth) was granted.
The state’s Motion to Strike the Defendant’s Motion to Exclude Unreliable Evidence Pursuant to Frye (Chloroform) was DENIED. The Courts believe it should be heard at the Frye Hearing, scheduled to start on March 23rd.
You can go to wesh.com to read the motions that were ruled on.
So now I guess we will see more motions filed by the Defense to get other evidence thrown out that they are certain will help find their client guilty. Baez must be twitching that smirky smile he has right now, trying to cover up his disappointment in the rulings made today.
Caylee Marie Anthony is the victim here, not Baez’s client. They need to remember that this precious little girl lost her life at no fault of her own. It was not her choice to die. I think it is about time that she is remembered and they start worrying about her getting justice in all of this and not about Casey Anthony being set free to go dance on poles again in her nightclubs, the same nightclubs that she claimed she was at only looking for her daughter during the month that Caylee had been missing before she was reported to anyone as being missing.
I pray that Caylee will get what is rightfully hers now, and that is Justice. Someone needs to make wallpaper with only Caylee’s picture and plaster it on Casey’s jail cell so she will be forced to remember this baby.
Jan Barrett













(9 votes, average: 4.44 out of 5)

11 users commented in " Casey Anthony Update: Judge Rules On Last Weeks Motions, Is Baez Still Smiling? "
Follow-up comment rss or Leave a TrackbackHi, Jan!
Thanks for the great article!
Today is a great day for the State of Florida vs Casey Marie Anthony!
Thanks to Judge Perry in that he is moving this case forward and as he stated a long time ago, this case will be tried in May, 2011!
I am still appalled that the Anthony’s thought they could manipulate and lie to obstruct justice. All of Cindy’s efforts (George too) came back to bite them in the butt! LMAO
I remember all of the drama Cindy attempted to create during her many TV appearances during 2008 and 2009.
Being I am from Texas, all I have to say to Cindy is, “That dog won’t hunt!” Folks from Texas should know what the popular saying in southeast Texas means!
~ ~ ~ Justice for Caylee Marie Anthony! ~ ~ ~
Jan,
Will you and Simon have a Radio Show this Sunday?
I hope so!
Thanks Jan for the update. I am so happy with these rulings. I agree with you someone should wallpaper Caseys cell with Cayle pic.Justice is long over due. I am ready for this trial to begin. Thanks again.
I think the only way out for Casey at this point is to beg for a plea bargain and throw herself on the mercy of the court. It is probably a bit too late for that option. These rulings are devastating to the defense. They will now have to explain all of her “mis-truths”, ( better known as a Cindyism). I just don’t know how they can possibly do that.
I CANT BELIEVE THAT WE FINALLY HAVE A JUDGE WHO KNOWS THE LAW, THANK GOD FOR HIM, JUDGE PERRY WE THANK YOU BECAUSE NOW THE TRIAL WILL BE ON TARGET, AND THE TRUTH WILL BE HEARD. I AM SORRY BUT I HAVE NO PITY FOR THE ANTHONYS, THEY TRIED THEIR BEST TO COVER FOR THEIR DAUGHTER , TELLING LIES AND EVEN A FAKE SUICIDE BY GEORGE, THAT ALL FAILED. SO NOW WE WILL HAVE JUSTICE FOR THAT ADORABLE INNOCENT CHILD CAYLEE, MAY SHE REST IN PIECE IN HEAVEN WITH ALL THE OTHER ANGELS, GOD BLESS HER MRS. NUGENT
All I can say is time is running out for the zanny story to resurface…especially since nobody has been out there looking for her. Not george, not cindy, not lee, not biaz…NOBODY, Don’t they realize that is as good as saying “My client lied again, there was no nanny…it was river cruz, or something dumb like that!
Thank you Jan for another great article. The defence team is almost out of options. I don’t understand why Jose doesn’t give up. He must know his client is responsible for Caylee’s death. He practically said so during this last hearing. Seems like the defense wants everyone to believe it was an accident and Casey was too afraid to tell her mom. So sorry Jose, we’re not buying it.
So far, seems like here is a judge that cannot be seduced by the wiles of Casey. Her inappropriate behavior and inappropriate clothes she is wearing to her court hearings are not (so far) affecting his sound judgement of the evidence that should come into the trial. Why should NOT the facts be evidence?
Still smiling? I’m sure nothing can wipe that goofy grin off Baez’ face.
Like his client, he so enjoys being in the spotlight, he doesn’t grasp the bigger picture.
I agree with the posters who said the only LOGICAL move here would be for Casey to finally ‘claim’ Caylee died accidentally & she panicked & things spun out of control. Given all the lies & the obstruction after that 911 call I don’t know if the judge would even buy this story BUT it’s the one ‘lie’ that even comes close to sounding halfway believable.
To do this, Casey would have to be willing to bypass the thrill of being the center of attention (she’s practically a LAWYER working with the brilliant Jose Baez now!) & she’d have to be willing to spare her family the horror of having all the rest of their dirty laundry laid out in front of the world. I just don’t think she wants to pass up the chance to thrust that knife the rest of the way into their hearts.
Besides, after she is convicted SHE’LL be the one who is the victim. She & her family can finally forget about Caylee & concentrate on the one who is suffering…. CMA. Heaven on earth for this sociopath.
After watching In Session’s hearings on Motionse motions concerning the smell of decomposition & chloroform in her TRUNK, I am truly amazed that she could sit between her attorneys and hear testimony about the dead child with absolutely no emotion, I am convinced that she is a sociopath. Right now she is pretending to be a paralegal or attorney rather than just sitting there twiggling her hair, her clothes, and obviously how she looks as she has done until only recently due to coaching by Baez. He should as her to TRY to muster up some fake emotion as she hears testimony about her decaying child! I would love to she her NOTES, especially during the State’s witness concerning the smells of chloroform and decaying bodies! Who does she think she is fooling??
I’m sure she could delve into the “method’s” way of acting and just think of how sorry she feels for herself. She obviously cannot feel for anyone else, including her parents, her friends.
Leave A Reply