It has been six weeks since we have had any Jail recordings concerning the Haleigh Cummings case. I touched base with the PIO for the St Johns jail today, and I was quite surprised by the conversation. I was merely asking what the schedule was for the release of more tapes.
He pointed out that there were no videos available, both Hank and Lisa are bound by their probation terms to stay within Putnam County. I countered with, ‘but there audio tapes’, these people do talk in the phone.
Yes there are recordings, and yes, they can be released.
Then came the zinger. Apparently BNN is the only news organization to ask for this information. As such we would have to pay for the manpower to create the CD’s. He went on to explain that in the past there had been 15-20 organizations interested, and so they had been able to share the manpower cost between the news organizations at the rate of $5 per DVD.
So folks, if you want to hear the latest audio tapes you are going to have to help us. No, we are not asking for money! We just need other news organizations to start asking for the tapes. If we can achieve that I am sure that the information will be made available at an equitable price.
I for one would love to hear the conversations between Misty and her family. I am also sure that there are some more very terse conversations between Tommy Croslin and his wife.
Toby Keith in his song American Soldier says ‘Freedom don’t come free’, this also applies to the Sunshine Law, Freedom Of Information has a price tag. I have a great deal of empathy with the Law Enforcement people, and realize that the LE dollar has to be stretched. I would rather that dollar be spent on solving the Haleigh Cummings case than fighting with CD’s on my behalf. The major issue is not creating the CD’s, but each conversation must be listened to, and redacted if required.
So folks, that is the story on the latest set of tapes.
I for one am somewhat surprised that BNN is the only organization interested in the information. But, as is so often the situation when covering news items, new cases take precedence over older ones.
It is possible that the interest level in the Haleigh Cummings case will gain some traction next week. There is a court appearance on July/6 that might just get some pens hitting the paper.
We will keep you informed of developments.
Simon and Jan Barrett
















38 users commented in " Florida’s Sunshine Law – The Fruit Comes At A Price! "
Follow-up comment rss or Leave a TrackbackWoW
sadly, I think for the most part the press has moved on until there is an arrest in Haleigh’s case. The ones in the weeks after the dock search, to me, are going to be the most interesting ones..
I know you didn’t ask for money but I wouldn’t mind chipping in to at least get the month of tapes since the dock search for both Misty and Tommy.
It is sad to think that the other news orgs aren’t interested anymore. Atleast BNN is still attempting to keep her story alive. THanks Simon and Jan.
I think those tapes could be the most interesting ones. I don’t know what to do to get them but hope someone comes up with an idea. Why the heck is BNN the only news org. still on it?! I don’t get it.
Thank you Simon and Jan for your diligence in keeping Haleigh front and center. I would be more than happy to donate for these tapes if we cannot find an alternative. God Bless Haleigh.
After seeing Werter on JVM last night I am not so sure Tommys allegations are warranted. I did realize if you need an attorney do not hire Werter! I do agree noones rights should be violated, but something is not right here.jmo
I’d be willing to send a donation and ask other organizations by email or letter to look into the case. I can not understand why they haven’t. Lets hope for Haleigh’s sake after next week they will.
Love to hear me some jail tapes from this bunch. Hope ngrace’s show will show some interest as well as AH. Whether we like them or not, they help get the tapes out there. We see what happens without them. High dollar tapes that can’t be afforded.
Maybe an anonymous benefactor looking to help solve the case will step up and pay for them to be done. Someone paid crystals back child support, so maybe there is hope.
I’ll shoot news stations in the area a email…thanks simon
Thanks Simon and Jan, maybe we should all start writing E-mails to news organizations ,I would also be willing to donate ,but if all the bloggers and readers here write I would imagine that would be a significant number of e-mails
If someone will post the email addys, maybe it would help if we wrote them.
How about a ball park estimate as to how much the DVD’s would cost. I just do not believe other news outlets are not on a list to be contacted when dvd’s are available. We here at BNN can pull together and make the purchase.. Simon we would have the Bomb Shell!! So Sorry NG, I guess she is not interested in the BALD TRUTH anymore ; ) jmo
Too much “VAN DER IDIOT” stuff right now, I guess.
I would bet we see some tapes released. The reporters “live” for the “scoop”.
Interesting show on JVM regarding Tommy. I cannot believe for a moment that the police browbeat Tommy for information, nor do I believe that they denied him contact with his lawyer. Werter was crying the blues on Tommy’s behalf yesterday but was this not the same lawyer who claimed that he knew who committed the crime against Haleigh and he could not wait to divulge that information?
For those of you that have Facebook Pages you can start here.
http://www.facebook.com/NancyGraceHLN
Tommy put himself into his situation and now he’s crying like a baby. Tut tut. In all honesty, I don’t care if LE beats him up one side and down the other. He’s thinking of his own hide and not caring one iota about Haleigh and those who REALLY love her. Shame on him. If he has truthful information, which I’m sure he does, he should tell. If he doesn’t know, why did he claim he did? Stupid, stupid.
No, I think the reason he’s not telling is because he’s decided (as have Ron and Misty) it’s best to take a drug charge than to be sentenced for murder and face a death penalty or life without parole. While I don’t think Tommy is the actual murderer, he was either a witness to it or a witness after the fact.
No matter what his involvement, he put himself into the middle of it by claiming he was there!!
Cry me a river, Tommy. Boo hoo. He’s a wimp and can’t take it when LE looks at him crooked. It’s time for him to grow up.
SALUKI said,
in July 3rd, 2010 at 5:25 pm
Interesting show on JVM regarding Tommy. I cannot believe for a moment that the police browbeat Tommy for information, nor do I believe that they denied him contact with his lawyer. Werter was crying the blues on Tommy’s behalf yesterday but was this not the same lawyer who claimed that he knew who committed the crime against Haleigh and he could not wait to divulge that information?
Yep, he is the same one.
WERTER: Well, you know, the people that interrogated him was Putnam County Sheriff`s office that day last week. One of the lead investigators was actually Florida Department of Law Enforcement, who has been aiding Putnam County. They never uttered those kind of threats. This came out of someplace else
VELEZ-MITCHELL: Well, what`s the whole point of this strong-arm tactics by — yes, it`s a threatening tactic. What are they trying to get? If he knows what happened and he went down to the river and told them what he knows, then why are they threatening him?
WERTER: We covered this before about where the body might have been since it was dumped into that part of the river. And I don`t really want to go over that because it is kind of gruesome. But the fact of the matter is, there`s problems with this case as to charging the person that should be charged. They`re thinking there`s something more. Or there`s inconsistencies between — minor inconsistencies between Tommy`s story and Misty`s story.
http://transcripts.cnn.com/TRANSCRIPTS/1007/02/ijvm.01.html
I got sidetracked by whimpy, whiny Tommy. Oops!
I wanted to say, if the public contacts the media, diligently, they may start requesting the tapes for St. Johns County and from Putnam County. The public needs to apply pressure to the media outlets to get this stuff released. I’m sure newspapers and television stations have more money at their disposal for this type of thing than do Jan and Simon.
Let’s contact the Florida newspapers, TV stations, NG, JVM, and Art Harris asking them to request this stuff. Just checked AH’s website and the last “news” item he posted was back on June 3rd. Has he been beamed into outer space or something?
Thank you Jan and Simon for all you do!!!!
how about: Larry King Live, Joy Behar, and CNN? They have easy email addresses right on their home page…
Simon/Jan kudos for being the savy ones to even THINK about jail house tapes… think about that!!!!!
Info for some of the area news media contacts:
St. Augustine Record
http://staugustine.com/contact
You can leave a message directly on that page
***
Palatka Daily News
Publisher: Rusty Starr rstarr@palatkadailynews.com
***
Channel 4 News4Jax
http://www.news4jax.com/contact/index.html
You can leave a message directly on that page
***
First Coast News
E-mail: news@firstcoastnews.com
Questions, comments and news tips for the News Department. This includes content of news and web stories
***
Local CBS 47 Station
News Contacts
Comment on Action News
news@ActionNewsJax.com
***
Florida Times-Union (Jacksonville Newspaper)
http://jacksonville.com/contact
You can leave a message directly on that page
***
I would have thought Thesky would have atleast asked. Set up a paypal and ill donate.
Can only news media request the CD/DVD’s? Or can private citizens of Florida also request them?
Hi Lady!!
hi, iloves, just checked back on this page and saw your message.
Lady sadie,
We all should appreciate your post with email addys, imo.
Thank you, that’s very nice of you to do put all that up.
np, jaba, figure if enough of us ask maybe they will request the tapes.
Also going to check on Tuesday to see if county residents can request the tapes on their own or if they have to be “media”.
You’d think one of the news outlets would pay for these tapes. Did everyone forget the focus is about a missing little girl?
I always thought once a prisoner had a lawyer nobody could question the prisoner without that counsel being present. I could care less about Tommy Croslin but how can they keep questioning him or harassing him on one thing when he is in jail for an entirely different offense?
I still think MOO Haleigh was taken out of the bad inviroment on purpose and maybe someone got paid off by which ever means for the helping hands. I bet she is very much alive.
All we would need is $100.00 then, 20 organizations $5.00 a dvd so if 20 of us donates $5.00 then we have it covered. Please set up a paypal and I’ll donate to it. Several others here are willing. :*)
Simon/Jan, could you let us know what the cost of the tapes is? If it is only $100, I’ll go pick them after the 15th and upload them to you.
Happy 4th of July to Jan, Simon, cobra, TJ, and all the participants here.
Simon, do you have any clue as to why a certain ‘field reporter’ is no longer blogging or on the NG or JVM shows? All communications on this topic ceased a month ago. Guess it’s a shame when one gets exposed.
Thought Hank could still leave the county, his probation order doesn’t say he cant and he did for months to visit Tommy. This sounds as strange as PC telling Simon they arent recording Ron because it’s too boring!
Simon, you know there have to be tapes of Tommy calling the Rents from jail. Would you try that avenue? Thanks for following up.
LadyDay/
Field reporter exposed for what?
Do the math .. 20 news outlets @ $5 per DVD is $100
Put up a pay pal donation link and I am sure we can get the $100 needed..
I will offer the first $1 for the account!!
@Dreamfinder
Just saw your comment, we had the same thought!
So sad this case is dwindelling….if it wasnt for Joran we would still be on track!
@LadyDay Are we talking about Art Harris as the “field reporter”? What was he exposed for? I personally cant stand him, but was just wondering if something happened.
Nancy Grace has her faults but, she her positives too. For one thing, if she showed interest in this case the tapes would be released.
I just wanted to add that seems like all the ridicule NG has received about her coverage of this case might have made her back off a bit. I remember when she said there was a human bone found in the river where allegedly Haleigh’s body was dumped. LE denied it and I recall people on your show chuckling about how wrong she was. Turns out there was a human bone after all.
Perhaps that’s why she doesn’t want to touch this case right now.
I’m not a big NG fan but, I don’t like to see her being made fun of either. NG has been reporting on crimes of this sort for years. Sadly, IMO her show has lost its heart. However, I feel that she should be given the respect she is due. She’s the one that get’s these cases in the public eye in the first place and that is worth its weight in gold and is worthy of our respect.
Leave A Reply