I accept that it is not easy for Muslims in India. But it was not like that before Babri Masjid demolition. The two communities do not trust each other after that. Muslims say it was due to Hindu fundamentalists(correction politicians). Hindus say that Muslims are anti-Hindu, they indiscriminately killed Hindus all over India when the Masjid was destroyed.

To change this you have to build more trust not make some baseless statements which will aggravate the problem even further.

We can discuss such things during peaceful times. But when terrorist attacks are happening such comments add more fuel to the already burning sentiments.

I am not against any religion. I am only for equality and fairness within society. But if you are going to stick Islamic in front of terrorists then you have to accept Hindu terrorists also exist. If you call yourself secular then the definition of secular needs to be examined. I used to be a proud Indian but now I am disgusted because in my mind, India is probably one of the most racist countries in the world. India is heading towards a path of destruction and I can only hope against hope someone stands up and saves us soon

The moment you mention “Bush” and “Jew” you are not Indian and you obviously are a fundamenatlist. Your only intention is to create a communal rift in India either to distract from the Mumbai attack or to create more trouble in India.

Trust me it is very true that people who “live by the sword, die by the sword”

You guys talk about Indians, what do you know about Indians? I do not want wish to go thru history to prove that Indians are secular. But there is no comparison between Islamic terrorism and Hindu terrorism for the following reasons.

I’m a very secular person. But with your anti Indian rhetoric you make me tell some truth which may seem communal. Here are the reasons

Islamic fundamentalists Hindu fundamentalists
No of known terrorists 10s of 1000s 5+
No of attacks by the groups 1000s 1
No killed by the groups 10s of 1000s 5
Nationality Mostly foreign(like you guys) Indian

It is obvious who is a bigger threat to India. You are comparing a mountain and a mole hole.
We can start to compare them when the Hindu fundamentalists start infiltrating Pakistan and kill thousands of people there.

Of course we have had roits. But the only time there was any real attrocities against Muslims was in Ghodhra , i.e. when you assume that the train fire was not started by muslims. The Mumbai roit was started by Muslims and Hindus retaliated when it did not stop after a couple of day. We have to remember that during this period there were many roits all over India started by Muslims and thousands of Hindus were killed and it is only in Mumbai that they retaliated. I’m from Bangalore and I have seen many roits in Bangalore where many Hindus were killed and many properties and temples damaged based on rumours or for the mistake of one person, like rumour that a mosque in Jayanagar was demolished or when a article with islamic name appeared in Deccan Herald, mistake of Editor, but many Hindus lost their lives, Babri masid demolished 1000s of miles away, not supported by 95% in south, but hundreds killed in Bangalore, Gulbarga, Hubli, Davangere etc. But there was no retaliation anywhere.

Also there is no parallel between Palestine and Kashmir. Palestine always belonged to Palestines and they are fighting for it. But Kashmir never belonged to the Muslims but they are claiming it by killing Hindus and chasing away all the Hindus. If the Muslims are Kashmiris, the Hindus are also Kashmiris who were there before the Muslims and even before these Hindus and Muslims settled there the land belonged to the Indians, to be more specific, even before the north Indians came the land belonged to the South Indians. Now the Majority (over 60%) of the Kashmir is in Pakistan and China. The attacks seen in the name of the small piece of land which is still in India is radiculous. FYI Jammu and Ladhak are not part of Kashmir.

So stop spreading your propaganda stuff.

Jai Hind

http://www.iwebie.com/antulay-vs-ekta-kapoor

If in case he was killed too… then people like Antulay would have claimed that the 10 dead terrorists were all Hindus…

Now, at the same time, I hope if an event repeats like this, our commandoes should try to capture atleast 2-3 terrorists alive and red handed so that people like Antulay wont be able to make remarks such as those blasphemous ones…

I first request a CT scan of the skull of Mr Antulay to see if everything is normal…

If everything is normal, do an EEG and then refer to a psychiatrist…

If the psychiatrist feels that everything is clinically normal with Mr Antulay, then Antulay SHOULD BE CHARGED AND BOOKED FOR BEING A TRAITOR

Hindu militancy is a reactionary response.

Antulay should be sacked on this ground as well. As a person who propels the growth Hindu militancy in India, through irresponsible comments.

(When FACTS are obvious, no one sane will go for logical possibilities. Antulay can doubt anyone, even a Martian, behind Mumbai massacre.

Sack him

This indicates how muslim votes are polarized and dictates the victory of politicians.

Among Hindus there is no unity and the vote gets devided between many parties. Hence politicians are giving second preference to Hindus in this country.

Jago hindu community. Spit/Shit on UPA.

Remove the word secularism from constitution.

That still does NOT excuse Antulay’s comments.

1) He is a politician with in a powerful position. He is supposed to protect minority interests. Considering the tension in the nation, HOW does it protect minority (or anyone’s?) interests to throw accusations around which will only work to split the nation amongst communal lines? Who gets hurt the most? Minorities.

2) No person in such a powerful position should be making ANY ACCUSATIONS without evidence. He has admitted he is not making the accusation on evidence, but conjecture. Its fine in random blog comments, but a minister of his position?

3) He has just given Pakistan A HUGE out at a time where we had pressure on them and were getting international support to make changes in the country. Even if this were true, a true minister would actually keep quiet, and do things required behind the scenes.

With his political position, an investigation could have EASILY been carried out behind the scenes to determine the truth behind these allegations, or even after a couple of months. Speaking out loud was irresponsible at best, and traitorous at worst.

And all this is assuming that he is absolutely right, and has inconclusive evidence. Contrary to the fact that he has admitted his statement is conjecture and nothing else.

We all know Karkare went to the hospital after Kasab and ismail got in there and started killing people.

Pakistan already said the 10 muslims from pakistan is creation of Hindu outfits in India. This is a stody. Now their media is singing Anthulay song as if it is a cabinet minister said so.

This bloody culprit who was handling positions in India was carrying so much junk in his mind means India is infected so much deep.

Now we need to start having a suspicious eye on all the junkies like him. E. Ahmad is on the top list here

Rama Brar. Toronto, Canada

He has just raised suspicious about the manner in which Karkare and three others died. Why you people ought to silence everybody.

Let there be a examination of call records of the officers who died to find out what directions control room gave and which inefficiency resulted in their running from one place to another in such a hurry

Terrorists like Pragya got support of Advani but nobody called him anti-national. However, when it comes to Antulay, demanding an inquriy, it is a crime.

Is it democracy or Hindutva-cracy?

Very soon, just like some of the people who are posting here, Pakistani terrorists will assume Indian Hindu names and divert the attention of public from the real terrorists. The Antulays will be there to help them.

It is to prevent such happennings that we need a very strict action against Mr Antulay. It is not feasible for Congress to take action against him since the party has exhausted all its courage in getting the two Bills passed and would like to take rest until the next elections.

It is for the people of India to make Antulay pay for his anti national activities.

Every person does not have the right to express his views on all incidences. If you read my previous post I just tried to prove the point that you can not express your meaningless/baseless and more impoirtantly harmful views on every thing.

People comment on blogs as they feel they are not accountable and they can not be caught. Not because they have the right.

People misunderstand the meaning of freedom. Freedom does not mean you can do anything. No country has any law which allows complete freedom. There are restrictions on every thing you do. Even in US if you can not go out naked. You can say it is your body and you are the one to decide if you want to display it or not.

But there rules to follow when you walk, talk, drive, work, marry, piss, shit etc etc.

The fact is you are leaving in a society and you have to live according to the written and unwritten rules of the society.

Nobody is supporting Malegaon here.

If you are a muslim you should know that the mumbai killing and Mr.Antualy comments have got nothing to do with muslims.

We are all humans and naturally we have some good ones and some bad ones in all the community.

Even the islamic terrorism was not create by muslims but by US.

Reaction to Antulays comments should not be taken as a comment on muslims. He does not represent muslims.

As far as Malegaon case and Mumbai attacks,both are anti National.

Investigations should be done properly and then only everyone should react sensibly.

As Buddha says peace,kindness,compassion is the only way out.

According to people like you it is simply asking a question.

What would be the reaction if we say that politicians have affairs and maybe their wives also have affairs. And since Mr Antukay spends more time with politicians than his family, so his children were not born to him?

Is it me simply asking a question? Or just trying to know the truth. I have my reasons to suspect it according to your logic. But I was not witness to anything. So can I still ask any such “simple questions”. Or should it be that I should ask a question when I have witnessed something.

It is a question of a person being responsible enough be aware of the consequences of such careless comments. The consequences are
1) You are putting some doubt into the minds of the muslims and as a result push some of them towards the enemy.
2) You are helping Pakistan get off the hook.

You just can not ask any question. You should only ask valid questions. If everybody simply starts asking questions then it means that everybody is questioning everybody else and it is not a very peaceful scenario. And then we would not have any defamation lawsuits if everybody is allowed to say anything.

You should realize that thousands of people have been killed and there were many communal roits in this country because people like him and you simply said something.

Do you know Babri masjid was destroyed because some politicians “Simply said something”

It is people like you who are killing the country. If you are from a minority community then you are biased which we can understand, everybody is a bit biased. But if you are an hindu you are such an ignorant fool.

The reason we do not want such statements is to maintain the peace and not to create any suspicions in the minds of the minorities.

People should have proper evidence before commenting on such sensitive issues.

dont even know the firing was started first at cst thus they guided towords…

center should sack him immidiately and should prob how much asshole took to make such stupid comments…

I agree with Pramod that such an investigation should include his financial status and income sources since his statement is definitely in favour of Pakistan and against the interest of India.

When we have bigger terrorist/political organisations at our disposal in India we don’t need outsiders to cause harm to our great Nation.

Long live Indians.. May these these inflictors of harm rot on roads or be lynched alive.

To safegurd these dumb people, the party is not inviting Ms.Priyanka to takeup the mantle, because, she is so intelligent that she will sack 90% of the current old, inept leaders..

Public must stone him for this talk.

Everything is crystal clear. Fukin invade Pak and Afghan countries and bury bullets in every terrorist’s head, for world’s good.

And as for Antulay, chop his toungue off. and hang him in public as a free stone target.

Let us remember, Mr. Antulay is the Minority affairs minister, so you can be rest assured that his focus is the interests of the minorities ……and like all politicians, he is an opportunist.

India is still a democracy and he has a right to his opinion, however, crass or self serving it may be.

If the government and agencies have done its investigation thoroughly and fairly, they should challenge Mr. Antulay to provide information that supports his claim or admit that he is speculating i.e. simply blowing smoke, through his orifices.

Don’t destroy the land of Lord Rama. We have a culture of 5000 years old. 500 year old culture is destroying the whole world.

May god bless India for having better politicians in future.

It is peace you desire you will not help the culprits get away.

Excluding Antulay’s baseless story everything else in the whole world points to Pakistan as the culprits. At this time any such comments are unwarranted. It is not just India which has the evidence, the whole world has evidence to prove this. If Pak was not nuclear it would have been a different story.

Making up stories or putting a spin to everthing is the bread and butter on which the politician and religious leaders survive but common people(assuming the people commenting are common people, very suspicious about it) should not support such baseless theories.

Why is it so easy to blame hindus in India without any evidence but if you have all the evidence and if blame the few people from minority community people are looked at as fundamentalist.

There is something fundamentally wrong in india

I agree with Vijay Pandit: “We have to always see who stands to BENEFIT from this particular act… ”

As far as I see it is only Pakistan who benifit from Antulay’s, Vijay Pandit’s and Rocky’s remarks

I also agree with Dr Swaroop R that there should be “AN INVESTIGATION TO SEE IF A R ANTULAY” and others are/”IS AN ACCOMPLICE OF ANY ANTI-INDIA ORGANIZATION”s

Why so much of hullabulla? Dont present your personal views. if we have the facts then express it here. just saying things on emotional background will not help.

What if what he is saying is truth? Lets have an enquiry and Search for the truth.

Mr Karkare was a brave leader we want to put all those who were behind this henious act to go behind bars.

Jai hind.

Why should we need to worry if we are Right?

For sake of other are we ready to leave or values.. how to speak and all.

It would be too naive of us to not look into it keenly

How do we put a petition or a forum to ASK for an investigation against A R antulay???

anyone with technical background help with this

traitor…

or may be dementia of Alzheimer’s disease

sad evening … i am feeling nausea, disgust and shock …. his statements…

i am always pro-BJP but very much for pro-secularism

now the only way congress can come clean is to SACK HIM and

that wont be enough… now Mr Antulay must be under investigation to vheck if he has any pro-pakistan ties….

still i am unable to come to terms… this idiot of an old man made such an anti-national remark not on some footpath… but the LOK SABHA…

bad dream is what i think i am experiencing

but….REAALLLY…. investigate MR ANTULAY to seee if he has any ties with anti-India organisations…

He has made an attempt to divide and destroy the secular fabric of India…

Three of my Muslim colleagues have already DISOWNED antulay

In my opinion the statements of Antulay and Ram Vilas Paswan are by themselves liable for prosecution as terror promotion.