According to most statistics, the buying public spent approximately $100 billion on gift cards last year. Because of their popularity, gift cards are used to commit fraud fairly frequently, also.
Retail criminals use fraudulent credit cards, debit cards and checks to buy large amounts of gift cards. Since a lot of sites exist, where anyone can sell these cards, criminals can turn them into cash fairly easily.
Shortly after the much talked about TJX data breach — where 90 million personal and financial records were compromised — a group was caught in Florida buying $8 million in gift cards using credit card numbers stolen in the data breach.
In another method to commit fraud, cards are picked up off a display and taken to a more private location in the store. The numbers and PINs are then recorded — either with a portable card skimmer, or written down by hand. The people doing this then simply call in to check the value of a particular card, and use them when they discover they’ve been activated.
I’ve seen articles written on this that recommend buying cards from behind a counter. While this may be safer, we have to remember that most retailers have a problem with dishonest employees. This is more prevalent during the holiday season, when retailers hire a lot of temporary help.
In wouldn’t be too far fetched to have a dishonest employee skim the details of these cards and drain them when they are activated.
There have also been reports of employees stealing credit card numbers and then using them to activate gift cards.
A couple days ago, TwinCities.com did a story about a Target employee stealing $19,500 in gift cards.
Since gift cards can be purchased on the Internet, fraudulent payment devices are used to purchase them on websites, also.
I would be extremely wary of buying any gift card on an auction, or gift card site. These sites rarely offer very much protection for people using them. It is a lot safer to visit the site that issues the cards, if you prefer shopping on the Internet.
Simply stated, a gift card purchased on a third-party website might not work, might not have the advertised value, or you might never receive what you bought.
I’m not saying not to buy gift cards. Being a lazy shopper, I buy them myself. Saying that, here are some tips to make sure you are getting what you pay for:
Make sure you buy them from a reputable retailer. Keep your receipt and if possible, use a credit card to purchase them. Credit cards offer a little extra protection if there is a problem. Inspect any card you buy for signs that it has been tampered. If the card is in a cardboard holder remove it and inspect it, the PIN should be protected up with a plastic coating that has to be scratched off.
Please note that if you work at a reputable retailer be wary of people returning gift cards. Stolen blank cards are often replaced for the cards that were previously activated.
I haven’t seen anything come out about gift card fraud from the National Retail Federation (NRF) this year yet, but here is an interesting press release they released on the matter last year.
















3 users commented in " Gift card due diligence 101 "
Follow-up comment rss or Leave a TrackbackMy gift card nightmare!
I recently had a horrible experience with Plastic Jungle (plasticjungle.com). I had a large number of gift cards to sell and was looking for a reputable company willing to purchase them. I went to their website and saw that they would purchase the cards. Since I had many cards at stake and I had never dealt with Plastic Jungle before, I did everything I could to ensure myself that they were an honorable website. I called them on 3 separate occasions and spoke to 2 plastic jungle employees. On the phone they were very courteous, ensured me that they are a very reputable company with rave reviews, and on top of that they were well funded. So I surely should trust them with selling my gift cards to them. I was walked through the website, shown exactly how and what to input into each field on their automated website and afterwards I received a receipt with a confirmation #. A couple hours later, I got a phone call from them stating that there was a mistake and they would pay less than their automated website said I would get. I really needed the money so I agreed to take the lower dollar amount. I sent them the cards through USPS registered mail and since and I insured the package for safe measures. Anxiously awaiting my check, I called them everyday until the package arrived. That’s when things started going sour. 3 days after the package arrived I called them to find out when I would be receiving my check and was told they made an error and they no longer wanted to buy the gift cards they had agreed to buy. As of now, I have not received the cards back, If and when I get them back - I will have to sell them at a much lower price (44 cents on the dollar). Its important to know that these websites are out to make a buck. They will agree to purchase the cards from you in order to get you to send your cards to them. When they get the cards, they will cancel the agreement if they think the cards have gone down in value or if they don’t think they can make a profit on them.
The secretary gave me several excuses - my cards are not good sellers so they can no longer buy them, there was a technical error on their website, the person who walked me through the web form on their website was filling in for someone else so he didn’t know what he was doing, and they don’t have the manpower to verify my gift cards.
This experience has led me to believe that PlasticJungle.com is a false advertising scam and I would stay away. As always BUYER BEWARE!!!
If you have a similar experience with any gift card site, please email me at Hostess4themostess@gmail.com and be sure to file a complaint with the Better Business Bureau. I’ve read plenty of horror stories ranging from buyers being misled to flat out gift card fraud. Hopefully through sharing of info, we can stop others from making the same mistake.
Hi
‘Due diligence’ most debatable topic. what are the possible mistakes (overlooked)by management in due diligence investigation (in merger and acqusition)?
Please give me your feedback.
Thank you
sravan
Great Article! If you want to learn more about due diligence you should read Due Diligence for the Financial Professional by L. Burke Files. It is a well written guide to the thought process and not just another book of mindless check lists.
http://www.amazon.com/Diligence-Financial-Professional-Burke-Files/dp/1886295085/ref=sr_1_1?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1293118781&sr=1-1
Leave A Reply